- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY 2024” Buffalo Spree magazine

-- Winner “Best ice cream in WNY 2024” Best of 716 Buffalo News

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY Northtowns 2023” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2023

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY 2022” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2022

- Roadfood.com awarded Legendary ice cream shop status

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY 2021” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2021

- Wanderlog.com best ice cream shop in Buffalo

- CNYNews.com best ice cream parlors in NY State

- Upstateunearthed.com “can’t miss ice cream parlors” in upstate NY

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY 2020” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2020

- Destinations on NY State “best ice cream parlors in the state”

- Matador Network’s list for most unusual ice cream flavors in the US

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in the Northtowns WNY 2019” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2019

- Union Sun and Journal reader poll “Best ice cream in Lockport”

- Union Sun and Journal reader poll “Best frozen yogurt in Lockport

- Union Sun and Journal reader poll “Best dessert in Lockport

- Destinations on NY State “best ice cream parlors in the state”

- 2018 Cover of Buffalo Spree magazine for best ice cream shop in buffalo

- Winner WIVB Channel 4 2018 Best ice cream in Buffalo

- Winner “Best ice cream shop (northtowns) in WNY 2018” Buffalo Spree magazine

- I Love NY.com 2018 13 best Ice Cream Parlors in NY State,

- 2018 35 Best Ice Cream Shops in Upstate NY State Ranked #3 Lake Effect Ice Cream -

Nyupstate.com

- 2018 Awarded 5 star “Legendary” ranking on National Roadfood.com website

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2018

- Union Sun and Journal reader poll “Best Ice Cream in Lockport

- Union Sun and Journal reader poll “Best dessert in Lockport

- Winner “Best ice cream shop in WNY 2017” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Winner Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2017

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2017

- 11 Best Ice Cream Parlors in NY State 2017 bestthingsny.com (Ranked #10)

- Winner “Best ice cream shop (northtowns) in WNY 2016” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2016

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2016

- Winner All WNY News 2016 Best ice cream in Buffalo

- Winner “Best ice cream shop (northtowns) in WNY 2015” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Winner Best dessert Taste of Lockport 2015

- Winner Best “healthy choice” Taste of Lockport 2015

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2015

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2015

- Winner “Best ice cream in WNY 2014” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Winner 2014 Lockport business of the year from the Lockport Business Association

- Winner Best dessert Taste of Lockport 2014

- Niagara USA Chamber 2014 Small Business award

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2014

- Tripadvisor Certificate of Excellence 2014

- Winner “Best ice cream stand in WNY 2013” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Winner Best dessert Taste of Lockport 2013

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2013

- Winner 2013 Social Media Awards of Buffalo “best use of social media by a food business”

- Winner “Best ice cream in WNY 2011” Buffalo Spree magazine

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2012

- Winner Best dessert Taste of Lockport 2011

- Nominee Best Ice Cream in Buffalo Artvoice 2011

- Invited to speak an attended Social Media Week conference in NYC

- Winner 2010 Buffalo Zoo Wines in the Wild event “Most Unique Offering”

- Winner “Best Guilty Pleasure WNY 2010” Buffalo Spree Magazine

- Winner Best dessert Taste of Lockport 2009